Skip to content

Free tracked postage on orders over $75 · $2.50 letter post on small ordersPostage details

Card Critter
Riddles in the Dark, Spotlight Series 12

MTG single

Riddles in the Dark

2 generic manaBlueInstant

Look at the top four cards of your library and separate them into a face-down pile and a face-up pile. An opponent chooses one of the piles. Put that pile into your hand and the other into your graveyard.

Not in stock yet

We list a single only once it’s graded and scanned front and back.

Notify me when it comes in

We’ll email you once when Riddles in the Dark is back in stock. No newsletter, no spam.

Protected by hCaptcha: Privacy & Terms.

Got one to sell? See what we pay

Every printing of Riddles in the Dark

3 printings · none in stock right now

  • Riddles in the Dark, Spotlight Series 12

    Spotlight Series

    12 · rare · 2026

  • Riddles in the Dark, The Hobbit 292

    The Hobbit

    292 · rare · 2026

  • Riddles in the Dark, The Hobbit 53

    The Hobbit

    53 · rare · 2026

How your card arrives

  • One card, one sleeveEvery card goes in its own penny sleeve and toploader. Never two to a sleeve.
  • Graded under a loupeCorners, edges, surface and centring checked, then scanned front and back. What you see is what goes in the toploader.
  • Posted next business day$2.50 letter post on small orders, and free tracked postage over $75.

How we grade·Postage and packing

More MTG singles

Shop all →