Skip to content

Free tracked postage on orders over $75 · $2.50 letter post on small ordersPostage details

Card Critter

Consignment

Pokémon card consignment

For higher-value cards: we scan, list, sell and ship them for you, and you keep 75–80% of the sale. Consignment opens soon. Register now to be first in.

How it works

You keep most of the sale

  1. 01

    Send your cards

    Post them in a prepaid satchel, or hand them over at a card show.

  2. 02

    We grade and scan

    Graded with our published guide and scanned front and back, like every card we sell.

  3. 03

    Listed at market

    Priced with the same method as our own stock, beside the market price.

  4. 0475–80%

    You get paid

    When it sells, you get 75–80% of the sale price. We handle postage, payments and returns.

Opening soon

Register for consignment

Tell us roughly what you’d consign and we’ll email you when consignment opens.

Protected by hCaptcha: Privacy & Terms.

Questions

Good to know

Can I sell or consign my cards?

Yes. Send us a list or photos and we will make an offer in cash or store credit, with a prepaid satchel to post them in. For higher-value cards you can consign instead and keep 75–80% of the sale price.

How is my offer worked out?

We pay 45% of the market price in cash, or 56% in store credit. That’s the same market price shown on our card pages, so you can check the maths. Whole collections get one offer for the lot, bulk included.

Cash or store credit: which should I take?

Store credit pays 25% more (56% vs 45%) and never expires, so it’s the better deal if you’ll buy from us. Cash is paid by bank transfer.

Do you buy bulk?

Yes, as part of a collection. Bulk commons and uncommons get a small per-card rate within the offer. We don’t make separate offers for bulk on its own.

What if you grade a card lower than I did?

We grade on arrival with our published grading guide. If a card comes in lower than described, we tell you the new offer for that card before paying, and you can have it back instead.