Skip to content

Free tracked postage on orders over $75 · $2.50 letter post on small ordersPostage details

Card Critter

Returns & refunds

Returns & refunds

If something’s not right with your order, we fix it. Your rights under the Australian Consumer Law always apply.

When we refund or replace

Contact us within 14 days of delivery if any of these happen and we’ll refund or replace the card.

  • Below the listed grade. The card is in worse condition than the grade on the listing.

  • Wrong card. A different card, printing or condition from the one you ordered.

  • Damaged in the post. The card arrived damaged. Keep the packaging and send us a photo.

  • Not genuine. Any card that isn’t authentic is refunded in full. See our authenticity guarantee.

How it works

Making a return

  1. 01

    Tell us

    Reply to your order email with your order number and a photo of the card, front and back.

  2. 02

    We check

    We compare it with our scan of the copy we sent and reply with the next step.

  3. 03

    Refund or replace

    Your choice. If it was our mistake, we cover the return postage.