Sell to Card Critter
Sell your Pokémon, Riftbound & MTG cards
Send us a list or a description, get an offer at a published rate, and post your cards free in our prepaid satchel. Cash, or 25% more as store credit.
How it works
Four steps, no account needed
- 01
Send your list
Paste card names, or just describe the collection. Photos help but aren’t required.
- 02
Get an offer
We email an offer at our published rate, card by card or one price for the lot.
- 03
Post them free
Accept the offer and we send a prepaid satchel. Nothing to pay up front.
- 04
Get paid
We check the cards against your list and pay by bank transfer, or as store credit straight away.
Our rates
Published rates, not mystery offers
We pay a fixed share of the market price: the same market price you see on our card pages. So you can work out your offer before you send anything.
Cash. 45% of the market price, paid by bank transfer.
Store credit. 56% of the market price: 25% more than cash, and it never expires.
Whole collections. One offer for everything, bulk included. No cherry-picking the hits and sending the rest back.
Graded on arrival. With our published grading guide. If a card comes in lower than described, you hear the new offer before we pay.
Start here
Get an offer for your cards
Tell us what you’ve got. We reply by email with an offer and the next steps.
High-value cards? Consider consigning
For chase cards and graded-quality singles, consignment usually pays more: we list, scan, sell and ship, and you keep 75–80% of the sale price.
Questions
Selling questions
Can I sell or consign my cards?
Yes. Send us a list or photos and we will make an offer in cash or store credit, with a prepaid satchel to post them in. For higher-value cards you can consign instead and keep 75–80% of the sale price.
How is my offer worked out?
We pay 45% of the market price in cash, or 56% in store credit. That’s the same market price shown on our card pages, so you can check the maths. Whole collections get one offer for the lot, bulk included.
Cash or store credit: which should I take?
Store credit pays 25% more (56% vs 45%) and never expires, so it’s the better deal if you’ll buy from us. Cash is paid by bank transfer.
Do you buy bulk?
Yes, as part of a collection. Bulk commons and uncommons get a small per-card rate within the offer. We don’t make separate offers for bulk on its own.
What if you grade a card lower than I did?
We grade on arrival with our published grading guide. If a card comes in lower than described, we tell you the new offer for that card before paying, and you can have it back instead.