MTG Singles Australia
Magic: The Gathering singles for Commander and beyond: commanders, staples and Secret Lair printings, graded, scanned and priced in AUD next to the US market. Cheaper staples come in our precon upgrade kits.
- Singles in stock
- 0
- Sets
- 0
- Scanned front & back
- Condition on every card
- $2.50 letter post
- Free tracked over $75
All MTG singles
34,037 cards · 0 singles in stock

Not in stockMTG
Piracy Charm
3 printings
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Piranha Fly
Duskmourn: House of Horror · 70
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Piranha Marsh
2 printings
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pirated Copy
2 printings
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pirate Hat
The Lost Caverns of Ixalan · 70
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pirate Peddlers
Avatar: The Last Airbender · 115
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pirate's Cutlass
4 printings
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pirate Ship
8 printings
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pirate's Pillage
2 printings
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pirate's Prize
2 printings
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pir, Imaginative Rascal
4 printings
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pirk, Heroic Captain
Unknown Event · RZ03n
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pir's Whim
2 printings
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Piru, the Volatile
4 printings
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Piston-Fist Cyclops
Guilds of Ravnica · 217
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Piston Sledge
Mirrodin Besieged · 124
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pistus Strike
Mirrodin Besieged · 86
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pit Automaton
Aetherdrift · 238
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pitchburn Devils
4 printings
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pitchstone Wall
2 printings
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pitfall Trap
3 printings
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pit Fight
3 printings
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pith Driller
New Phyrexia · 69
Notify me

Not in stockMTG
Pithing Needle
15 printings
Notify me
After $1 trainers, energy or bulk staples? Every single is listed on its own here, however cheap, and a few post as a $2.50 letter. Building a whole deck? Our deck kits come with the basics thrown in.
Shop deck kitsGot a binder of doubles?
Sell or consign your Magic cards. Cash or store credit at a published rate, and we send the prepaid satchel.
Questions
Good to know
Isn’t it cheaper to import from TCGplayer or Hareruya?
For one or two cards, rarely. TCGplayer Direct charges US$15.99 shipping to Australia plus GST and your card’s FX fee, and every card page shows that landed cost next to our price. For a big list of cheap cards, importing can win, and we’ll say so.
How do you set your prices? Are they fair?
We start from the US market price, convert it to AUD at the day’s rate, and add our margin for grading, scanning and stocking the card here: 25% on the first $10, 20% above. We never charge more than it costs to import the card yourself. Each card page shows our price next to that market price and the import cost, so you can check us rather than eBay solds.
Is the card in the photo the one I’ll get?
Every single is scanned front and back. Listings marked “Our scan” show the exact copy you’ll receive. Where a listing still shows a reference image, that copy is scanned before it ships, and we’re happy to send you the photos first.
Is your near mint really near mint?
We grade every card NM, LP, MP, HP or DMG using our published grading guide, and the grade is on every listing. If a card arrives below the grade we listed, we refund it.
How much is postage if I only want a couple of cards?
$2.50 untracked letter post for a few singles under 5mm thick. Tracked is $9.95 and required on orders over $50, and orders over $75 ship tracked for free. Every card goes in a penny sleeve and toploader, never several cards jammed into one.
Can I buy a $1 card on its own?
Yes. Every single is listed on its own, however cheap. A few singles post as a $2.50 letter, each in a penny sleeve and toploader. Building a whole deck? Our deck kits come with the basics thrown in.
What if my order doesn’t arrive or something’s wrong?
Contact us and we’ll sort it out. A real person replies, not a form. Your rights under the Australian Consumer Law apply to every order, and tracked postage is available on any order.
Card Critter sells MTG singles with the price method on show: every card page compares our AUD price with the US market and the cost of importing it yourself.